When was 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ last sold?

The most recent recorded sale was in 2018 for $257,500.

What is the assessed value of 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ?

The total municipal assessment is $304,200 (land plus improvements).

What is 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ worth?

Our model estimates a market value of $471,914, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.

How many units does 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ have?

Records show 1 dwelling unit at 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ.

ElasticParcelNJ

Loading…

58 Cozy Lake Road

Jefferson, NJ 07438·Morris County

1414·block 482·lot 7

Estimated market value

$471,914

high confidence

range $421,695 – $488,276

Assessment-implied: $436,317; Director's Ratio 0.6972 (2025)
Comp-implied: $483,779; 30 comparable sales

Last sale

$257,500

12/13/2018 · taxrecords_nj

Property

Type

Residential 1-4 unit

Tax class

Residential 1-4 unit

Year built

1968

Building size

1,671 sq ft

Lot size

0.22 ac

Land description

0.217 AC

Building description

1.5SF

Dwelling / commercial units

1 dw / 0 comm

Tax & Assessment

Net assessed value

$304,200

Land value

$121,300

Improvement value

$182,900

Last year's tax

$9,132

Last MOD-IV sale

$257,500

MOD-IV deed date

12/6/2018

Owner

WANAMAKER, KYLE/LEANA

58 Cozy Lake Rd
Oak Ridge, NJ 07438

Sales history

12/6/2018$257,500
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 23464 / Pg 1234
9/8/2016$119,000
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 23210 / Pg 277
6/30/1999$167,500
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 5005 / Pg 121
3/30/1992$133,500
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 3584 / Pg 272

Date	Price	Book / Page	Source
12/6/2018	$257,500	23464 / 1234	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
9/8/2016	$119,000	23210 / 277	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
6/30/1999	$167,500	5005 / 121	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
3/30/1992	$133,500	3584 / 272

On Cozy Lake Road

Block 482

Debug — raw data per source

Computed

{
  "isCondoMaster": false,
  "condoCluster": null,
  "siblingUnitCount": 0,
  "portfolioCount": 0,
  "portfolioKeys": {
    "fullKeys": [
      "58 COZY LAKE RD OAK RIDGE NJ 07438"
    ],
    "zipKeys": [
      "58 COZY LAKE RD 07438"
    ]
  },
  "effective_unit_count": 1,
  "effective_unit_count_source": "MOD-IV"
}

MOD-IV

{
  "pams_pin": "1414_482_7",
  "county_code": "14",
  "district_code": "14",
  "block": "482",
  "lot": "7",
  "qualifier": "",
  "property_location": "58 COZY LAKE RD",
  "property_class": "2",
  "bldg_class": "17",
  "bldg_desc": "1.5SF",
  "land_desc": "0.217 AC",
  "year_built": 1968,
  "living_sqft": 1671,
  "dwelling_units": 1,
  "comm_dwell": null,
  "land_value_cents": "12130000",
  "improvement_value_cents": "18290000",
  "net_value_cents": "30420000",
  "last_yr_tx_cents": "913209",
  "deed_date": "2018-12-06",
  "deed_book": "23464",
  "deed_page": "1234",
  "sale_price_cents": "25750000",
  "sales_code": null,
  "owner_mailing_street": "58 COZY LAKE RD",
  "owner_mailing_city_state_zip": "OAK RIDGE, NJ  07438",
  "mun_name": "JEFFERSON TWP",
  "calc_acre": "0.216900",
  "add_lots1": null,
  "add_lots2": null,
  "prop_use": null,
  "fac_name": null,
  "centroid_lon": -74.50621338503652,
  "centroid_lat": 41.014001065393565
}

SR1A

[
  {
    "id": "d8629dc6-81e0-492d-b117-c459628e50fc",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23464",
    "deed_page": "1234",
    "deed_date": "2018-12-06",
    "date_recorded": "2018-12-13",
    "sale_price_cents": "25750000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "f53efa19-ebec-460c-8952-da8b7d163cab",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23464",
    "deed_page": "1234",
    "deed_date": "2018-12-06",
    "date_recorded": "2018-12-06",
    "sale_price_cents": "25750000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  },
  {
    "id": "d658a308-0968-4ebe-ac63-70210bef318d",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23210",
    "deed_page": "277",
    "deed_date": "2016-09-08",
    "date_recorded": "2017-09-21",
    "sale_price_cents": "11900000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "332adfa9-1097-4962-ae21-315f39d4ef30",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23210",
    "deed_page": "277",
    "deed_date": "2016-09-08",
    "date_recorded": "2016-09-08",
    "sale_price_cents": "11900000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  },
  {
    "id": "5714d5b7-e788-4343-b466-2ca35436deb4",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "5005",
    "deed_page": "121",
    "deed_date": "1999-06-30",
    "date_recorded": "1999-07-06",
    "sale_price_cents": "16750000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "7513af6e-91bd-4f93-9db2-1342626d07e1",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "5005",
    "deed_page": "121",
    "deed_date": "1999-06-30",
    "date_recorded": "1999-06-30",
    "sale_price_cents": "16750000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  },
  {
    "id": "ad0a5a9a-7275-48a5-a085-7a364615aff8",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "3584",
    "deed_page": "272",
    "deed_date": "1992-03-30",
    "date_recorded": "1992-03-30",
    "sale_price_cents": "13350000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  }
]

API record·permalink

Frequently asked

When was 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ last sold?: The most recent recorded sale was in 2018 for $257,500.
What is the assessed value of 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ?: The total municipal assessment is $304,200 (land plus improvements).
What is 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ worth?: Our model estimates a market value of $471,914, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.
How many units does 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ have?: Records show 1 dwelling unit at 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ.
What kind of property is 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ?: It is a Residential Property.

Loading parcel record…

58 Cozy Lake Rd

58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ — owner, sales, deeds · ElasticParcel

58 Cozy Lake Road

Jefferson, NJ 07438·Morris County

1414·block 482·lot 7

Estimated market value

$471,914

high confidence

range $421,695 – $488,276

Assessment-implied: $436,317; Director's Ratio 0.6972 (2025)
Comp-implied: $483,779; 30 comparable sales

Last sale

$257,500

12/13/2018 · taxrecords_nj

Property

Type

Residential 1-4 unit

Tax class

Residential 1-4 unit

Year built

1968

Building size

1,671 sq ft

Lot size

0.22 ac

Land description

0.217 AC

Building description

1.5SF

Dwelling / commercial units

1 dw / 0 comm

Tax & Assessment

Net assessed value

$304,200

Land value

$121,300

Improvement value

$182,900

Last year's tax

$9,132

Last MOD-IV sale

$257,500

MOD-IV deed date

12/6/2018

Owner

WANAMAKER, KYLE/LEANA

58 Cozy Lake Rd
Oak Ridge, NJ 07438

Sales history

12/6/2018$257,500
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 23464 / Pg 1234
9/8/2016$119,000
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 23210 / Pg 277
6/30/1999$167,500
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 5005 / Pg 121
3/30/1992$133,500
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 3584 / Pg 272

Date	Price	Book / Page	Source
12/6/2018	$257,500	23464 / 1234	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
9/8/2016	$119,000	23210 / 277	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
6/30/1999	$167,500	5005 / 121	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
3/30/1992	$133,500	3584 / 272

On Cozy Lake Road

Block 482

Debug — raw data per source

Computed

{
  "isCondoMaster": false,
  "condoCluster": null,
  "siblingUnitCount": 0,
  "portfolioCount": 0,
  "portfolioKeys": {
    "fullKeys": [
      "58 COZY LAKE RD OAK RIDGE NJ 07438"
    ],
    "zipKeys": [
      "58 COZY LAKE RD 07438"
    ]
  },
  "effective_unit_count": 1,
  "effective_unit_count_source": "MOD-IV"
}

MOD-IV

{
  "pams_pin": "1414_482_7",
  "county_code": "14",
  "district_code": "14",
  "block": "482",
  "lot": "7",
  "qualifier": "",
  "property_location": "58 COZY LAKE RD",
  "property_class": "2",
  "bldg_class": "17",
  "bldg_desc": "1.5SF",
  "land_desc": "0.217 AC",
  "year_built": 1968,
  "living_sqft": 1671,
  "dwelling_units": 1,
  "comm_dwell": null,
  "land_value_cents": "12130000",
  "improvement_value_cents": "18290000",
  "net_value_cents": "30420000",
  "last_yr_tx_cents": "913209",
  "deed_date": "2018-12-06",
  "deed_book": "23464",
  "deed_page": "1234",
  "sale_price_cents": "25750000",
  "sales_code": null,
  "owner_mailing_street": "58 COZY LAKE RD",
  "owner_mailing_city_state_zip": "OAK RIDGE, NJ  07438",
  "mun_name": "JEFFERSON TWP",
  "calc_acre": "0.216900",
  "add_lots1": null,
  "add_lots2": null,
  "prop_use": null,
  "fac_name": null,
  "centroid_lon": -74.50621338503652,
  "centroid_lat": 41.014001065393565
}

SR1A

[
  {
    "id": "d8629dc6-81e0-492d-b117-c459628e50fc",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23464",
    "deed_page": "1234",
    "deed_date": "2018-12-06",
    "date_recorded": "2018-12-13",
    "sale_price_cents": "25750000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "f53efa19-ebec-460c-8952-da8b7d163cab",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23464",
    "deed_page": "1234",
    "deed_date": "2018-12-06",
    "date_recorded": "2018-12-06",
    "sale_price_cents": "25750000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  },
  {
    "id": "d658a308-0968-4ebe-ac63-70210bef318d",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23210",
    "deed_page": "277",
    "deed_date": "2016-09-08",
    "date_recorded": "2017-09-21",
    "sale_price_cents": "11900000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "332adfa9-1097-4962-ae21-315f39d4ef30",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "23210",
    "deed_page": "277",
    "deed_date": "2016-09-08",
    "date_recorded": "2016-09-08",
    "sale_price_cents": "11900000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  },
  {
    "id": "5714d5b7-e788-4343-b466-2ca35436deb4",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "5005",
    "deed_page": "121",
    "deed_date": "1999-06-30",
    "date_recorded": "1999-07-06",
    "sale_price_cents": "16750000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "taxrecords_nj"
  },
  {
    "id": "7513af6e-91bd-4f93-9db2-1342626d07e1",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "5005",
    "deed_page": "121",
    "deed_date": "1999-06-30",
    "date_recorded": "1999-06-30",
    "sale_price_cents": "16750000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  },
  {
    "id": "ad0a5a9a-7275-48a5-a085-7a364615aff8",
    "property_id": "1727a3f8-e957-4e69-afef-7c1c6f44030b",
    "county_code": "14",
    "district_code": "14",
    "block": "482",
    "lot": "7",
    "qualifier": "",
    "deed_book": "3584",
    "deed_page": "272",
    "deed_date": "1992-03-30",
    "date_recorded": "1992-03-30",
    "sale_price_cents": "13350000",
    "sr1a_year": null,
    "source": "modiv_rutgers"
  }
]

API record·permalink

Frequently asked

When was 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ last sold?: The most recent recorded sale was in 2018 for $257,500.
What is the assessed value of 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ?: The total municipal assessment is $304,200 (land plus improvements).
What is 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ worth?: Our model estimates a market value of $471,914, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.
How many units does 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ have?: Records show 1 dwelling unit at 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ.
What kind of property is 58 Cozy Lake Road, Jefferson, NJ?: It is a Residential Property.

Based on 30 comparable sales

Address	Sold	Price
3 Loretta Ln	4/8/2026	$630,000
237 Prospect Pt Rd	3/30/2026	$510,000
5504 Berkshire Valley Rd	3/20/2026	$370,000
18 Marine Ter	3/13/2026	$435,000
49 N Lakeside Ave	3/12/2026	$675,000
120 New Jersey Ave	3/5/2026	$440,000
33 Shore Rd	2/24/2026	$550,000
17 Rosemont Rd	2/20/2026	$590,000
11 White Birch Trl	2/13/2026	$478,000
202 Espanong Rd	1/23/2026	$720,000
28 Highland Rd	1/23/2026	$515,000
34 Hillside Ave	1/21/2026	$290,000
7 Shenandoah Cres	1/14/2026	$515,000
16 Waterside Dr	1/12/2026	$310,000
9 Commodore Dr	12/24/2025	$495,000
131 S Maryland Ave	12/15/2025	$440,000
134 E Shawnee Trl	12/8/2025	$360,000
20 Mc Nabb Rd	12/5/2025	$550,000
8 Lenape Trl	12/5/2025	$262,500
23 Oriole Rd	12/3/2025	$420,000
60 Woodlawn Ter	12/3/2025	$574,500
12 High View Ter	11/21/2025	$370,000
9 Millburn Dr	11/21/2025	$410,000
5 Delaware Ave	10/27/2025	$469,000
S Beach Rd	10/22/2025	$350,000
32 Sachem Rd	10/22/2025	$232,700
645 Berkshire Valley Rd	10/21/2025	$370,000
36 Hillside Ave	10/15/2025	$280,000
10 Fawn Ter	10/14/2025	$680,000
25 Alabama Ave	10/1/2025	$433,000

Estimated market value

Property

Tax & Assessment

Sales history

Frequently asked

Estimated market value

Property

Tax & Assessment

Sales history

Frequently asked

Deeds