When was 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ last sold?

The most recent recorded sale was in 2010 for $380,000.

What is the assessed value of 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ?

The total municipal assessment is $404,800 (land plus improvements).

What is 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ worth?

Our model estimates a market value of $706,716, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.

How many units does 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ have?

Records show 1 dwelling unit at 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ.

ElasticParcelNJ

Loading…

Save searches, owner alerts, and pro features

37 Old Creamery Road

Andover Twp, NJ·Sussex County

Estimated market value

$706,716

high confidence

range $409,587 – $1,300,319

Assessment-implied: $727,011; Director's Ratio 0.5568 (2025)
Comp-implied: $699,951; 25 comparable sales

Based on 25 comparable sales

Address

Last sale

$380,000

4/9/2010 · County clerk

Owner contactPro · unlock

DCA-registered owner email, phone, and authorized agent are available on Pro.

Property

Type

Residential 1-4 unit

Tax class

Residential 1-4 unit

Year built

1997

Building size

3,420 sq ft

Lot size

2.24 ac

Land description

2.24 ACS

Building description

—

Dwelling / commercial units

1 dw / 0 comm

Tax & Assessment

Net assessed value

$404,800

Land value

$91,300

Improvement value

$313,500

Last year's tax

$17,054

Sale on tax record

$380,000

Deed date

3/24/2010

Owner mailing addressPro · unlock

Owner name and mailing address are available on Pro.

Sales history

3/24/2010$380,000
Tax assessorBk 3247 / Pg 305
4/16/1996$41,000
Tax assessorBk 2141 / Pg 287
10/13/1989$0
Tax assessorBk 1688 / Pg 213

Date	Price	Book / Page	Source
3/24/2010	$380,000	3247 / 305	Tax assessor
4/16/1996	$41,000	2141 / 287	Tax assessor
10/13/1989	$0	1688 / 213	Tax assessor

Deeds

Properties on Old Creamery Road

Properties on Block 34

Frequently asked

When was 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ last sold?: The most recent recorded sale was in 2010 for $380,000.
What is the assessed value of 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ?: The total municipal assessment is $404,800 (land plus improvements).
What is 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ worth?: Our model estimates a market value of $706,716, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.
How many units does 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ have?: Records show 1 dwelling unit at 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ.
What kind of property is 37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ?: It is a Residential Property.

1902·block 34·lot 4.01

Loading parcel record…

37 Old Creamery Rd

37 Old Creamery Road, Andover Twp, NJ — owner, sales, deeds · ElasticParcel

12 Goodale Rd	3/13/2026	$475,000
4 Garry Ln	2/17/2026	$875,000
45 Luchetti Way	2/9/2026	$650,000
33 Huntsville Rd	12/1/2025	$665,000
11 Macintosh Dr	9/26/2025	$780,000
16 Dorset Ln	8/13/2025	$875,000
12 Ridge Rd	8/12/2025	$400,000
8 Macintosh Dr	7/11/2025	$808,000
7 Autumn TR	7/8/2025	$735,000
11 Tanglewood Dr	7/7/2025	$800,000
40 Hemlock Ave	7/3/2025	$1,250,000
17 Wisteria Rd	5/23/2025	$866,000
36 Cambridge Rd	3/7/2025	$640,000
31 Hemlock Ave	1/2/2025	$588,000
33 Huntsville Rd	11/5/2024	$350,000
19 Dana Dr	10/18/2024	$685,000
188 Andover Sparta Rd	6/5/2024	$627,500
4 Tallyho Ln	5/13/2024	$625,000
12 Ridge Rd	5/6/2024	$3,596,100
6 Marlene Ln	12/28/2023	$660,000
12 Marlene Ln	12/28/2023	$660,000
35 Huntsville Rd	11/8/2023	$599,000
111 Andover Mohawk Rd	9/27/2023	$680,000
11 Tallyho Ln	8/3/2023	$770,000
4 Garry Ln	6/13/2023	$750,000

Estimated market value

Owner contact🔒Pro · unlock

Property

Tax & Assessment

Sales history

Deeds

Frequently asked

Estimated market value

Owner contact🔒Pro · unlock

Property

Tax & Assessment

Sales history

Deeds

Frequently asked

Owner contactPro · unlock

Owner contactPro · unlock