When was 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ last sold?

The most recent recorded sale was in 2009 for $10.

What is the assessed value of 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ?

The total municipal assessment is $400,700 (land plus improvements).

What is 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ worth?

Our model estimates a market value of $589,950, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.

How many units does 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ have?

Records show 1 dwelling unit at 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ.

ElasticParcelNJ

Loading…

Save searches, owner alerts, and pro features

12 Starlight Road

Jefferson, NJ 07438·Morris County

Estimated market value

$589,950

high confidence

range $523,301 – $677,346

Assessment-implied: $574,727; Director's Ratio 0.6972 (2025)
Comp-implied: $595,025; 30 comparable sales

Based on 30 comparable sales

Address	Sold

Last sale

$10

6/3/2009 · TaxRecords NJ

Property

Type

Residential 1-4 unit

Tax class

Residential 1-4 unit

Year built

1960

Building size

2,054 sq ft

Lot size

0.42 ac

Land description

0.420 AC

Building description

1SF G

Dwelling / commercial units

1 dw / 0 comm

Tax & Assessment

Net assessed value

$400,700

Land value

$156,000

Improvement value

$244,700

Last year's tax

$12,029

Last MOD-IV sale

$10

MOD-IV deed date

5/9/2009

Owner

BUTTENMULLER, JENNIFER J/THOMAS

12 Starlight Rd
Oak Ridge, NJ 07438

Sales history

5/9/2009$10
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 21308 / Pg 1209
5/17/2002$295,250
MOD-IV (Rutgers)Bk 5622 / Pg 70

Date	Price	Book / Page	Source
5/9/2009	$10	21308 / 1209	MOD-IV (Rutgers)
5/17/2002	$295,250	5622 / 70	MOD-IV (Rutgers)

Deeds

No deeds on file. Click Fetch metadata to pull the title chain from the county clerk.

Properties on Starlight Road

Properties on Block 458

Frequently asked

When was 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ last sold?: The most recent recorded sale was in 2009 for $10.
What is the assessed value of 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ?: The total municipal assessment is $400,700 (land plus improvements).
What is 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ worth?: Our model estimates a market value of $589,950, derived from comparable recorded sales nearby.
How many units does 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ have?: Records show 1 dwelling unit at 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ.
What kind of property is 12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ?: It is a Residential Property.

1414·block 458·lot 9

Loading parcel record…

12 Starlight Rd

12 Starlight Road, Jefferson, NJ — owner, sales, deeds · ElasticParcel

3 Loretta Ln	4/8/2026	$630,000
16 Prospect Pt Rd	3/10/2026	$644,000
59 Sachem Rd	3/5/2026	$540,000
5461 Berkshire Valley Rd	2/27/2026	$525,000
17 Rosemont Rd	2/20/2026	$590,000
141 Milton Rd	2/19/2026	$510,000
202 Espanong Rd	1/23/2026	$720,000
28 Highland Rd	1/23/2026	$515,000
148 Schoolhouse Rd	1/23/2026	$515,000
33 Shawnee Pkwy	1/23/2026	$570,000
36 S Cherry Rd	1/15/2026	$470,000
7 Shenandoah Cres	1/14/2026	$515,000
124 Chincopee Rd	1/9/2026	$1,400,000
23 Patterson Dr	12/30/2025	$575,000
9 Commodore Dr	12/24/2025	$495,000
45 Hillside Ave	12/18/2025	$480,000
44 Summit Rd	12/9/2025	$539,900
8 Lenape Trl	12/5/2025	$262,500
16 Sunset Ln	12/4/2025	$615,000
60 Woodlawn Ter	12/3/2025	$574,500
111 Prospect Pt Rd	12/2/2025	$285,000
7 Wild Rose Rd	12/2/2025	$375,000
8 2nd Lt Jt Wroblewski Ln	11/7/2025	$725,000
2 Venice Ln	10/28/2025	$305,000
S Beach Rd	10/22/2025	$350,000
141 Milton Rd	10/14/2025	$415,000
2 Windsor Dr	10/9/2025	$542,500
17 Hopi Trl	10/1/2025	$530,000
46 Cozy Lake Rd	9/4/2025	$562,000
19 Choctaw Trl	8/25/2025	$464,000